NGraph

Augustiner-Bräu: company structure analysis (Arche)

A

Augustiner-Bräu

Craft· 500yr+ Legend·698 years·GermanyGermany, 1328
78
/100

Society

8/10

Customer

10/10

Self

8/10

3 above the excellence line

Survival 47Excellence 75

Munich's oldest brewery. It runs no advertising and keeps its independence by placing a majority of its shares in a foundation.

12 criteria

44/60

+

3 axes

26/30

+

Bonus

+8

=

NCG

78/100

Bonus: [Time+Strategy+Impact] 698yr+Munich's oldest brewery+no advertising+a foundation holds the majority, putting it beyond sale

Context

In 1294 the Augustinian Hermits founded a monastery just outside Munich and built a brewery there in the early 14th century. The brewery is first mentioned by name in 1328. The monks left with the secularisation of 1803, and in 1817 the brewery moved to Neuhauser Strasse. In 1829 Anton and Therese Wagner, a brewing couple from near Freising, bought it. In 1883 it moved to a new building on Landsberger Strasse, and the first brew there followed the next year. In 1996 Edith Haberland-Wagner, the last relative to bear the Wagner name and the main owner, left her shares to a foundation she had set up; the foundation still holds the majority. Since 1987 it has been the only one of the six Munich breweries at Oktoberfest to serve solely from wooden kegs. It does not advertise, and in a 2019 interview the chair of the foundation said it will not start.

TelesTeles' Insight

What people say about Augustiner is mostly what it does not do. It does not advertise. It does not give up wooden kegs. It does not change its bottle. What I notice, though, is one decision in 1996. Edith, the last relative with the Wagner name, left her shares to a foundation she had set up herself. From then on the majority of the company could not be sold even if someone wished to sell it. Keeping up a 'we don't' for decades takes more than resolve. The company had to be placed where the pressure to sell could not reach it. Restraint may be less about holding desire down than about building, in advance, a form in which desire has nothing to act on. Will the things you refuse to do still be refused after you are gone?

Key to survival

It began as a monastery brewery, lost its owner in the secularisation and was taken on by one family in 1829. The last head of that family left her shares to a foundation instead of spreading them among heirs. The accumulated 'we don't' of no advertising, no giving up wooden kegs and no change of bottle can continue only because the ownership cannot be bought out. Here restraint rests not on attitude but on structure.

12 Criteria (44/60)

StrengthsC Solution, E Traction, F Moat, L Insight

WeaknessesJ Exit

AMarket3/5

Beer is a mature market. Within it, the brewery is rooted in Munich and has drinkers beyond the city too.

BProblem3/5

Once bought by a major group, taste and method are decided by margins. It needed a way to stay independent.

CSolution5/5

A majority of the shares was left to a foundation, putting the company beyond sale. It also runs no advertising.

DTeam4/5

The Wagner family since 1829. Since 1996 the foundation has held the majority, chaired by a family descendant (as of 2019).

ETraction5/5

It spread beyond Munich without advertising. At Oktoberfest it is the only brewery serving solely from wooden kegs.

FMoat5/5

The standing of Munich's oldest brewery, wooden kegs, an unchanged bottle shape and an ownership structure that cannot be sold.

GRevenue4/5

Bottled and draught beer, plus continued investment in its own restaurants and beer halls.

HFinancial3/5

Private, with no detailed figures published. With a foundation holding the majority, pressure for short-term payouts is low.

IEfficiency3/5

Wooden kegs take extra handling. On the other hand it carries no advertising budget.

JExit1/5

The majority is held by a foundation. Neither a sale nor a listing is contemplated.

KTiming3/5

In 1996, by the will of the last family head, the foundation came to hold the majority. The succession question was not passed on to the next generation.

LInsight5/5

It fixed 'not for sale' as an ownership structure rather than leaving it to one person's will.

See other cases

View all cases

NGRAPH — AI ADOPTION SUPPORT

We start AI adoption by understanding how your business is built

At NGraph, engineers come into your workplace, look at your work, decisions and the data you use, and then build AI in. We don't stop at teaching you how to use it: we leave AI in a form your team keeps using.