NGraph

Mercari: company structure analysis (Arche)

M

Mercari

Startup·JapanJapan, 2013
71
/100

Society

8/10

Customer

8/10

Self

6/10

24 above the survival line

Survival 47Excellence 75

Sold to people Yahoo Auctions wasn't serving. Created a new market rather than fighting for the old one.

12 criteria

43/60

+

3 axes

22/30

+

Bonus

+6

=

NCG

71/100

Bonus: [Impact+Strategy+Capital] Japan's C2C unicorn+US expansion; 13yr

Context

Shintaro Yamada (who had previously sold Unoh) brought the 'mobile flea market' concept to Japan. Instead of competing head-on with dominant Yahoo Auctions, he entered through a completely different segment: women in their 20s. 50,000 users in three weeks.

TelesTeles' Insight

Mercari's playbook is Japan's textbook 'don't fight competitors, create a new market.' Yahoo Auctions was dominant but PC-centric, auction-format, male-oriented. Yamada saw young women's smartphone time exploding and cut in with single-photo listings, fixed pricing, and escrow. The 50,000 users in three weeks weren't stolen from Yahoo — he created a new behavior for the smartphone generation.

12 Criteria (43/60)

StrengthsK Timing

WeaknessesF Moat, H Financial

AMarket4/5

Japan's used-goods market is worth trillions of yen. But 'C2C on smartphone' was unproven.

BProblem4/5

Yahoo Auctions was PC-centric, auction-format, male-oriented. Young women couldn't use it.

CSolution4/5

One photo to list, fixed pricing, escrow payment. 10x simpler than Yahoo Auctions.

DTeam4/5

Shintaro Yamada: Unoh exit plus Zynga experience. A mobile-and-growth specialist.

ETraction4/5

50,000 users and 10,000 listings in three weeks. Staggering initial velocity.

FMoat2/5

Listing volume is the value. But LINE or Yahoo could clone the app.

GRevenue4/5

Free at launch; fees on the sale price began in October 2014 (now 10%). A clean C2C marketplace model.

HFinancial2/5

Too early for detailed financials.

IEfficiency3/5

$500K seed to 50,000 users in three weeks. Efficiency is high.

JExit3/5

Few Japanese unicorns; IPO precedent is limited.

KTiming5/5

2013 was peak iPhone adoption. Young women's smartphone time was exploding.

LInsight4/5

Sold to people Yahoo Auctions wasn't serving. Didn't fight the competitor — created a new market.

See other cases

View all cases

NGRAPH — AI ADOPTION SUPPORT

We start AI adoption by understanding how your business is built

At NGraph, engineers come into your workplace, look at your work, decisions and the data you use, and then build AI in. We don't stop at teaching you how to use it: we leave AI in a form your team keeps using.