Slack
Slack
USA, Founded 2009
Society
6/10
Customer
6/10
Self
4/10
2 above the survival line
Society
6/10
Customer
6/10
Self
4/10
2 above the survival line
Post-Flickr-exit second act. Building an MMO called Glitch — the chat tool was still just an internal utility.
12 criteria
32/60
3 axes
16/30
Bonus
+1
NCG
49/100
Bonus: [Insight] Foreshadowing of Glitch-failure-to-chat pivot; founders not yet aware; only Flickr-exit credit
Context
Stewart Butterfield left Yahoo! and founded Tiny Speck in 2009 with co-founders Cal Henderson, Eric Costello, and Serguei Mourachov. With $5M in funding, the team focused on a browser-based collaborative MMORPG called 'Glitch.' Backed by Accel and Andreessen Horowitz on the strength of Butterfield's track record, the chat tool that would later become Slack remained an internal byproduct used to coordinate game development. Glitch wouldn't reach open beta until September 2011 and would shut down a year later (December 2012). At this stage, nobody thought the chat side was the real product.
Teles' Insight
Tiny Speck 2009 scored NCG 32 — looking at it as a gaming company, just a normal early-stage startup. They raised $5M, hired 30+ people, and spent over two years failing to ship Glitch's beta. Nobody thought the chat tool was the real product. The Slack thread was being written underwater as 'an internal tool to streamline our own dev.' What's unusual about Butterfield is the conviction to come back instead of retiring after the Flickr exit. The Glitch-to-chat pivot came December 2012 — and the fastest unicorn run in history started there. Insight=4 even at this early NCG reflects historical credit for a foreshadowing the founders themselves hadn't yet noticed.
Key to survival
Capital, brand, and the trust of a former Flickr team — earned via the Flickr exit — enabled the 'second attempt' to pivot from a failed game into a chat tool. A normal founder would have run out of cash before three years.
12 Criteria (32/60)
StrengthsD Team
WeaknessesE Traction, F Moat, G Revenue, H Financial, I Efficiency, J Exit
The Flash browser-game market was growing but tilting casual under Zynga's rise. Collaborative MMORPGs were a niche with few successes.
'Have fun with friends in a virtual world' was a real desire, but World of Warcraft already dominated. Differentiation was the challenge.
A Flash-built browser MMO. Daily retention and monetization were tough; as a game it didn't reach a 10x experience.
Butterfield had sold Flickr to Yahoo! for ~$25M; Cal Henderson was former Flickr CTO. World-class product × community talent.
Open beta was still two years away. As of 2009, the product wasn't public.
None. The Flash gaming space had no entry barrier and was easy to copy.
Planned in-game item monetization. By era social-gaming standards, unit economics were unproven.
~$5M Series A (Accel + Andreessen Horowitz). The Flickr exit's credit pulled in the early capital.
A 30–40 person team, no shipped beta for over two years. High burn, low efficiency.
Few gaming-company IPOs. Acquisition exits were unreadable given Zynga-class threats.
Peak Flash gaming, transitioning to HTML5 — a technology-choice risk. On the other hand, the cloud + SaaS wave had begun.
'Start from your own team's pain.' The internal chat tool built to coordinate Glitch development would become the real product later — but at this stage, even Butterfield didn't see it.
